题目 15 范文:支持 B(全民基本收入有害)
I agree with Paul that universal basic income may cause more harm than benefit. Paying every citizen would require a very large government budget, which could lead to higher taxes or cuts to schools and hospitals. It is also inefficient to give the same payment to wealthy people and families in real need. Claire is right that financial security reduces stress, but targeted programs can provide housing, food, and job training more directly. A universal payment might also reduce the reason for some people to accept available work, creating labor shortages. Governments should improve existing social services and make them easier to use. This approach can protect vulnerable citizens without creating the enormous cost and uncertain effects of a permanent payment to everyone.